The Sue Bigelow Spirit Shield is named in honour of the late Sue Bigelow in remembrance of the work and contribution that Sue made to inclusive programming at the ACC. The winner of the award will be the school that most embodies the ACC maxim of “Sport in the Right Spirit” and has provided its students with outstanding inclusive opportunities for participation, team spirit, personal development and leadership.
| YEAR | SWIMMING | FUN RUN | ATHLETICS |
| 2007 | Corpus Christi College | ||
| 2008 | Sacred Heart College | ||
| 2009 | Mercedes College | ||
| 2010 | Christchurch Grammar | ||
| 2011 | La Salle College | Christchurch Grammar | La Salle College |
| 2012 | John XXIII | Mercy College | Corpus Christi |
| 2013 | Mandurah Catholic | Newman College | Mandurah Catholic |
| 2014 | Seton Catholic College | Corpus Christi | La Salle College |
| 2015 | Ursula Frayne Catholic | Sacred Heart College | Prendiville Catholic |
| 2016 | Lumen Christi College | Mercedes College | La Salle College |
| 2017 | John XXIII College | Lumen Christi College | Mercy College |
| 2018 | Prendiville Catholic | EVENT CXL | Corpus Christ College |
| 2019 | Mercedes College | EVENT CXL - COVID | Lumen Christi College |
| 2020 | Event CXL - COVID | EVENT CXL - COVID | Seton Catholic College |
| 2021 | Corpus Christi College | Servite College | Sacred Heart College |
| 2022 | Event CXL - COVID | Lumen Christi College | John XXIII College |
| 2023 | Corpus Christi College | Sacred Heart College | Ursula Frayne College |
| 2024 | La Salle College | Seton Catholic College | Holy Cross College |
| 2025 | Christ Church Grammar | La Salle College | Corpus Christi College |
| 2026 | Seton Catholic College | Newman College |